you're reading...
Education, Find Out More, Government Policy, New Zealand, NZEI, Parata (Hekia), Pay Issues, Performance Pay for Teachers, Teachers' Own Words

Nothing to see here: blinkers and bullcrap

nothing to see hereI went to a union meeting yesterday.  I’m not working at the moment, but wanted to know more about what is being discussed and how teachers on the ground are feeling, so off I trundled.  I must say, I was so taken aback by some of what I heard that I came home and fell asleep for most of the night, shocked into stupor.

The first shock was when we were asked to quickly list with others on our tables what is going on in education at the moment. As I didn’t know anyone and was there to listen more than speak, I waited.  There was a pregnant pause, then one someone quietly said:

Well, nothing’s going on in education at the moment, is it …. because it’s an election year and they want to stay safe.”


For real?

Stunned, I paused to see what others thought…

“There’s performance pay,” said one.

“No, she was misquoted,” someone replied.


… and still I stayed quiet. (It was killing me, but I needed to listen not talk).


And that was it.

There seemed to be more talk at other tables, so this may not be representative, but it still made me want to cry.

I just kept thinking, is this really all the knowledge, interest and passion this group of 7 teachers has between them about their own profession?  Do they truly not know any more than that, or do they not care?  How on earth do we get them to care?

If there had been a bar, I’d have turned to drink.

A better list (but not the whole list)

Luckily, when the rep went around the room asking what people had identified, the list was long and people sounded more outraged by it all.  Not all, but many seemed frustrated.

Between them, this smallish group of about 60 teachers listed National Standards, charter schools, PaCT, charter schools, the killing off of the Teachers Council, performance pay, decile ratings, funding of schools, change principals and the $359 for new roles.

The teacher that had said nothing much was happening in education was nodding – she had known about all of those things at the back of her mind.

Hekia’s school propaganda tour 2014

wonka asks Hekia have you got an answerThe meeting went on.  Performance pay was mentioned again. Two lots of teachers said they had asked Hekia Parata face-to-face when she had visited their schools in the past couple of weeks whether she was considering performance pay and Hekia had responded that she was misquoted and not to believe all they read.

This is when my cork popped.  Performance pay, I pointed out, is something Hekia Parata has talked about since 2012 and they should perhaps not believe all they hear from the Minister either.

People looked a bit stunned. They had fronted up and asked the Minister first hand whether she was considering performance pay and they felt she had said no it wasn’t.

But, I asked, did she say it was OFF the table or merely say she was misquoted?  And di they teachers realise she has been mooting performance pay since 2012?

The teachers were now confused as they had felt they had gotten an answer from the horse’s mouth and now it seemed maybe not. They asked the rep to ask the union to ask the Minister for clarification – is there to be performance pay or not?

No point, I mused inwardly. Because this is how she answers straightforward questions about performance pay (and anything else, in fact):

On the meeting went… and the horrors unveiled later are best saved for another post…

Meanwhile, concerned teachers and whanua reading this, you have colleagues, friends and family who believe nothing much is happening in education.  Maybe you need to start some conversations to counter that belief, before it’s too late.


Further reading on Hekia’s performance pay stance: (in 2012) (in 2012)—NZEI/tabid/1607/articleID/336162/Default.aspx


About Save Our Schools NZ

"One needs to be slow to form convictions, but once formed they must be defended against the heaviest odds." Gandhi


11 thoughts on “Nothing to see here: blinkers and bullcrap

  1. Hopefully the round of paid union meetings next week will clarify the thoughts of members..


    Posted by Glenn Cassidy | April 2, 2014, 12:46 pm
  2. Omg. Just about to go help run my local PUM.I dread what lit they know.


    Posted by Melulater | April 2, 2014, 3:08 pm
  3. Reblogged this on My Thinks and commented:
    There’s a comprehensive list of postings about performance pay at the end of this post. Thanks Dianne!!


    Posted by boonman | April 2, 2014, 5:59 pm
  4. Dianne Keep quiet at your table???? First lie you never stopped talking and how dare you speak about me as one of the seven at that table as if I was an idiot!! I (unlike yourself I have been working hard all term at the chalk face ensuring my class is engaged and learning that is my job.! After a day where I had got up at 5:30 and worked all day I turned up at a union meeting (more than most teachers in the area). From the start you dominated the table conversation and myself and the teacher beside me discussed how that cut us off from being able to share!!! So I am really offended by your comments and your misquotes and the comments that you never added.


    Posted by miss | April 2, 2014, 7:53 pm
    • And to say I don’t care about my profession or have passion for a job that I give so much of my time and life to is really offensive. You don’t even know me or what I do and you certainly never listened to ME!!


      Posted by miss | April 2, 2014, 8:01 pm
      • I am in no way questioning yours or anyone at the table’s passion for teaching. But that first half of the meeting was alarming in that people seemed unaware of the political goings on outside the classroom. I did indeed speak up eventually, yes. And so did others at the table. But that initial silence from aside from one person was indeed disconcerting. If anything, it reminded me that teachers are far too busy teaching to keep up with what is going on, and that is something for me and others to bear in mind.


        Posted by Dianne - SaveOurSchoolsNZ | April 3, 2014, 11:03 am
  5. Jeez teachers, take a look outside. I’m an escaped teacher, nearly 20 yrs now, but honestly, are you that badly treated? I work in a university now, we’re even worse off, but the bosses do explain the finances to us. The economic miracle has been hard going for all of us. It’s just life in the corporate twenty-tens.


    Posted by Gregor | April 2, 2014, 8:36 pm

Share your thoughts:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow Save Our Schools NZ on

Category list:


%d bloggers like this: